Steffany is one of the most accomplished twirlers in the world. She was a member of the U.S. Twirling Team in 2009, 2012, and 2015 and won 6 gold world championship titles, including World Strut Champion, World Solo Champion, World 2-baton Champion, and World Rhythmic Champion. She holds 14 gold national titles, including the U.S. Grand National Champion, U.S. National Solo Champion, U.S. National Strut Champion, U.S. National 2-baton Champion and U.S. National Rhythmic Champion. Additionally, she was gold medalist for the World Open 3-Baton Championship for 7 consecutive years. In 2016, Steffany was named Miss Majorette of America and in 2017 she was named Collegiate Miss Majorette of America.